Who was ‘a consistent threat’? Newcastle v Arsenal player ratings

This post was originally published on this site.

Who was ‘a consistent threat’? Newcastle v Arsenal player ratings

Noni Madueke and Harvey Barnes battle for possession during Arsenal's draw at NewcastleImage source, Getty Images
  • Published
By

Football reporter at St James’ Park

Arsenal and Newcastle played out an entertaining 2-2 draw at St James’ Park on Saturday.

The Gunners took the lead through Eberechi Eze in the first half before Harvey Barnes equalised after the break.

The hosts went ahead when Malick Thiaw bundled in from a corner before Noni Madueke brought the Gunners level with an excellent strike, and that is how it finished.

BBC Sport’s Alex Howell has rated the players – and you can have your say too.

Newcastle United

Lukas Hornicek: His kicking was slightly erratic. Nearly got caught on the ball by Kai Havertz after taking too long to release it. Could have done better with the second Arsenal goal. 5

Amar Dedic: Booked after pulling back Eberechi Eze and had a tough evening against the England forward. 5

Malick Thiaw: Scored the goal to put Newcastle in front, which capped an excellent performance in central defence. 8

Dan Burn: Some crucial clearances in the first half and played a big part as Newcastle took the lead. 7

Lewis Hall: A big error for the opening goal when he failed to deal with a clipped ball over the top. The left back redeemed himself with a crucial block to deny Noni Madueke and provided some excellent deliveries into the Arsenal box. 7

Sean Steur: Showed quality on the ball and a calmness you do not often see in an 18-year-old, but taken off at half time. 6

Lewis Miley: Quality on the ball and worked well with Steur. Was the deepest of the Newcastle midfield in the second half. 7

Jacob Murphy: An early shot and tried to catch David Raya off his line, but also taken off at the break after a quiet first half. 5

Joe Willock: An all-action performance and his physicality was a big reason why Newcastle improved in the second half. 7

Harvey Barnes: An excellent finish to bring Newcastle level and was always direct. 8

William Osula: Isolated as he led the Newcastle attack but did very well to assist his side’s opening goal. 7

Subs:

Tino Livramento (on 46, Dedic): Made a huge impact after coming on at half-time. 7

Anthony Elanga (on 46, Murphy): His pace meant Newcastle always had an option in behind. 6

Jacob Ramsey (on 46, Steur): Added drive to the midfield. 7

Sven Botman (on 92, Hall)

Subs not used: Pope, Schar, Gonzalez, Wissa, Fernandez-Pardo.

Arsenal

David Raya: Was taken off with what looked like a serious shoulder problem after conceding twice. 5

Jurrien Timber: Arsenal used the Dutchman’s aerial ability to get up the pitch quickly. Picked up some dangerous positions when the Gunners had the ball. 6

Ezri Konsa: The centre-back looked to be cruising before Arsenal conceded twice in the second half. 6

Gabriel Magalhaes: Got caught up in a battle with Osula as Arsenal conceded a second to go behind. 6

Riccardo Calafiori: A quieter attacking display than usual from the marauding left-back. 6

Declan Rice: Started the game very well but could not stop the Newcastle turnaround. 7

Bruno Guimaraes: Had to deal with a hostile reception whenever he was on the ball. Should have scored in the first half with a great chance and then taken off. 5

Martin Odegaard: An uncharacteristic mistake to gift Newcastle a way back into the match, but then made amends by setting up Madueke. 6

Eberechi Eze: Scored the opening goal of the game with a powerful finish. Looked sharp and provided an outlet. 7

Noni Madueke: Lots of positive moments from the winger and scored a great goal to bring Arsenal level. A consistent threat. 8

Kai Havertz: Plenty of smart play and almost nicked a goal when he closed down Hornicek. Provided a great pass for Eze’s goal. 7

Subs:

Kepa Arrizabalaga (on 70, Raya): Made a couple of smart stops. 6

Myles Lewis-Skelly (on 70, Guimaraes): A solid performance from the bench. 7

Christos Tzolis (on 70, Eze): Worked hard after coming on. 6

Merino (on 94, Odegaard)

Gyokeres (on 94, Havertz)

Subs not used: White, Mosquera, Saliba, Hincapie.

How did you rate the players?

The Player Rater cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable JavaScript or try another browser.

Player of the match

Number: 11 H. Barnes

Average rating 7.07
Number: 11 H. Barnes

Average Rating: 7.07

Number: 33 D. Burn

Average Rating: 6.78

Number: 12 M. Thiaw

Average Rating: 6.76

Number: 2 T. Livramento

Average Rating: 6.76

Number: 41 J. Ramsey

Average Rating: 6.46

Number: 3 L. Hall

Average Rating: 6.40

Number: 67 L. Miley

Average Rating: 6.37

Number: 28 J. Willock

Average Rating: 6.35

Number: 19 A. Elanga

Average Rating: 6.33

Number: 10 W. Osula

Average Rating: 6.18

Number: 4 S. Botman

Average Rating: 5.90

Number: 14 S. Steur

Average Rating: 5.87

Number: 23 J. Murphy

Average Rating: 5.81

Number: 21 L. Horníček

Average Rating: 5.72

Number: 37 A. Dedić

Average Rating: 5.64

Number: 9 Y. Wissa

Average Rating: 5.29

After the opportunity to rate players has closed, the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users.

Hot this week

BREAKING: Record-Setting WWE Champion Returns To AEW; Released Just 6 Weeks Ago

A record-setting WWE champion has finally returned to AEW....

Ranking 12 Best Cowboys Players Who Are Not In The Hall of Fame Yet

#12 Cornell Green " srcset="https://www.sme-insights.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/5e7df-17953199481606-1920.avif?w=190 190w,...

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Credit Check mission

GTA 6's Credit Check mission brings back the best...

AEW Star To Return For WWE Royal Rumble, Charlotte Flair Teases

Charlotte Flair has spoken out and revealed that an...

Topics

BREAKING: Record-Setting WWE Champion Returns To AEW; Released Just 6 Weeks Ago

A record-setting WWE champion has finally returned to AEW....

Ranking 12 Best Cowboys Players Who Are Not In The Hall of Fame Yet

#12 Cornell Green " srcset="https://www.sme-insights.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/5e7df-17953199481606-1920.avif?w=190 190w,...

GTA 6 walkthrough: How to complete Credit Check mission

GTA 6's Credit Check mission brings back the best...

AEW Star To Return For WWE Royal Rumble, Charlotte Flair Teases

Charlotte Flair has spoken out and revealed that an...
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img