Dallas is 4-6, last in the NFL in total defense, and a week removed from a home loss to San Francisco in which the 49ers gained 584 yards, the most an opponent has ever posted at AT&T Stadium. Jerry Jones did not reach for encouragement.
“We have not been a good team and are a bad team,” he said on 105.3 The Fan. “At 4-6, that says everything you need to say.”
Thanks for the submission!
The NFC East keeps the season breathing: the Giants lead at 5-3-1, and the Cowboys play two losing teams in the next five days.
•
![]()
1. Give Mike Pettine a Simpler Defense That Protects Deep

Looking to predict NFL playoff Scenarios? Try our NFL Playoff Predictor for real-time simulations and stay ahead of the game!
Dallas has allowed nine plays of 50 yards or more, according to the Associated Press, nearly twice as many as any other team. The team’s own film review counts 48 plays of at least 20 yards, worth 1,534 yards and eight touchdowns. San Francisco found four routes to the end zone on Nov. 15: Christian McCaffrey’s 74-yard catch-and-run, a 66-yard touchdown to McCaffrey against an all-out blitz, Deebo Samuel’s 70-yard reverse and a 25-yard run by rookie Kaelon Black.
Mike Pettine, the senior defensive assistant, took the headset this week. He has called plays in the NFL for a decade, so this is a simplification rather than a rebuild: fewer bodies near the line of scrimmage, two safeties who stay on top of vertical routes, and coverage rules plain enough for a secondary missing DaRon Bland and starting a rookie in Caleb Downs. Schottenheimer called it “a different perspective,” not a new defense.
If it works, opponents start needing twelve plays instead of one. Dallas does not have to be a top-10 defense to win this division. It has to stop giving up six points on a single snap.
2. Fix the Run Defense and Get Off the Field on Third Down
Two numbers at the bottom of the league sheet feed each other: rushing yards allowed at 154.1 per game and a third-down conversion rate allowed of 48.8%. The Cowboys are also last in defensive EPA per play at minus-0.13. Schottenheimer named the cause plainly. “What’s killing us, missed tackles and explosive plays,” he said after the 49ers game. A miss on first down creates third-and-short, and third-and-short keeps the chains moving.
Quinnen Williams is holding up his end. He leads the league with 15 tackles for loss, has six sacks, the most by a Dallas defensive tackle in a season since 2017, and three forced fumbles, per ESPN. He is winning his gap. The players stacked behind him are not.
Heavier fronts on early downs, more snaps for true linebackers and live tackling in practice would all help. So would one unpopular rule: on third-and-1, the safeties cannot align 15 yards deep. Dallas averages 28.6 points per game, fifth in the league, and is still 4-6. Three extra stops on a Sunday changes that arithmetic.
3. Hand the Cowboys’ Offense Back to Javonte Williams
Prescott has thrown 387 passes, more than any quarterback in the league, and the Cowboys look most like themselves when he does not have to. Javonte Williams has 154 carries for 629 yards, a 4.1 average, and nine rushing touchdowns, tied for second in the NFL. His best afternoon came in the 38-21 win at Philadelphia: 25 carries, 155 yards, a score and an offense that never let the Eagles settle.
That game is the blueprint. Twenty to 25 carries for Williams, Tyler Smith and T.J. Bass moving in the same direction, and play-action buying the room Prescott has spent two months manufacturing by hand. It also protects a defense that cannot survive long fields and quick three-and-outs. Dallas averaged 125.6 rushing yards per game in 2025 and 94.1 over its first eight games this season, per ESPN.
A Prescott attempt count in the low 30s would suit everyone. He has won that way before.
4. Hold the Line Without Booker and Bland
Both injuries are high ankle sprains, and they cost the Cowboys in different rooms. Booker, the second-year right guard, is PFF’s fourth-highest graded guard at 83.0 and its top run blocker at 90.5, per Sports Illustrated’s Cowboys site. Bland went down on San Francisco’s first touchdown drive and has been placed on injured reserve, according to the same outlet. Jake Ferguson (knee/ankle), P.J. Locke (concussion) and Jonathan Mingo (ankle) were also ruled out for Sunday.
T.J. Bass answers at right guard. He started four games at left guard earlier this season while Tyler Smith recovered from thumb surgery, and Schottenheimer calls him “Mr. Versatility.” His 66.5 grade is a downgrade, though the gap scheme does not have to change. In the secondary, Cobie Durant and Downs need help over the top, which is one more argument for the two-deep shell.
The same runs stay available for Williams, and the young corners are asked to do less while Bland recovers.
5. Treat the Next Two Home Games as a Division Series

The wild card is not a realistic door. Dallas is 0-9-1 against NFC teams outside the East in Schottenheimer’s two seasons, per ESPN data, which leaves the division as the only route. ESPN’s Football Power Index had the Cowboys at 42.0% to win the East before Week 11, with the Giants at 53%. New York also draws Jacksonville, San Francisco and Seattle in three of its next four games.
That makes Sunday against Tennessee (1-8) and Thanksgiving against Philadelphia (2-7) close to elimination games. Dallas is 1-3 at AT&T Stadium this season and beat the Eagles 38-21 in Week 7, so home advantage needs reclaiming. Schottenheimer set the standard himself: “If we don’t make the playoffs, it’s a failure. The season’s a failure. That’s what we play for.”
Win both and the Cowboys are 6-6 with a December bye, a Week 17 home game against the Giants and a closing trip to Washington. Lose one and the last five weeks become an audition for 2027. The division is weak enough to keep this alive. Dallas has to stop being the reason it ends.
Edited by Aman Kashyap


