Self-Promotional Content Works—Until It Backfires (AI SEO Experiment)

This post was originally published on this site.

When self-promotional content worked

The clearest result came from Ahrefs Evolve, our new SEO & AEO conference.

Instead of looking only at total brand mentions, I looked at places where a specific AI assistant, answering a specific query, had not mentioned the brand at all during the Feb 7–12 baseline.

After the first pages went live on Feb 13, Evolve broke into 72 of those previously empty slots. Of the 72 new Evolve mentions in prompt-engine slots that had been empty before publishing, 82% appeared in answers that cited one of our pages.

That’s the cleanest evidence that the pages did something. The brand went from absent to present, and four times out of five, our page was the cited source.

Promoting Ahrefs Brand Radar told the opposite story.

Ahrefs was already an established brand, so AI assistants named it across many relevant searches with or without our help. When Ahrefs broke into a previously empty slot, only 6% of those new mentions came from answers that cited one of our pages. The other 94% came from third-party content.

Bar chart showing only 6% of new Ahrefs mentions came from our pages while 94% came from third-party contentBar chart showing only 6% of new Ahrefs mentions came from our pages while 94% came from third-party content

So the self-promotional pages seemed to matter much more for the new brand than the established one. For Ahrefs Evolve, the content often acted like the bridge between “not mentioned” and “mentioned.” For Ahrefs Brand Radar, AI already had plenty of other sources to work from.

Copilot was the AI assistant with the most mentions. Evolve went from essentially zero before launch to 39% of Copilot answers in March, 57% in April, and 65% in May. Gemini picked it up too, but less steadily. Perplexity barely moved. ChatGPT never named Evolve for this query at all.

Line chart of Ahrefs Evolve mentions in Copilot answers rising to 39% in March, 57% in April, 65% in MayLine chart of Ahrefs Evolve mentions in Copilot answers rising to 39% in March, 57% in April, 65% in May

And just for the record, here are some of the pages I created to promote Brand Radar and Ahrefs Evolve:

Examples of self-promotional pages published to promote Ahrefs Brand Radar and Ahrefs EvolveExamples of self-promotional pages published to promote Ahrefs Brand Radar and Ahrefs EvolveMore examples of self-promotional listicle and review pages created for the experimentMore examples of self-promotional listicle and review pages created for the experiment

Hot this week

‘You’ve been trying to kill me for 23 years’ – should Ronaldo start?

'You've been trying to kill me for 23 years'...

Is this a breakthrough moment for soccer in the US?

Is this a breakthrough moment for soccer in the...

Wegovy weight loss pill now available in UK – here’s what you need to know

The once-a-day pill, from the makers of the Wegovy weight-loss jab, can now be bought privately in UK pharmacies.

The numbers behind Spain defence chasing World Cup history

The numbers behind Spain defence chasing World Cup historyImage...

Topics

Is this a breakthrough moment for soccer in the US?

Is this a breakthrough moment for soccer in the...

Wegovy weight loss pill now available in UK – here’s what you need to know

The once-a-day pill, from the makers of the Wegovy weight-loss jab, can now be bought privately in UK pharmacies.

The numbers behind Spain defence chasing World Cup history

The numbers behind Spain defence chasing World Cup historyImage...

How England’s epic night at the Azteca unfolded

Relive all the drama from England's 3-2 win over...

How England’s epic night at the Azteca unfolded

Relive all the drama from England’s 3-2 win over Mexico, as Thomas Tuchel’s team progressed to a quarter-final meeting with Norway on Saturday.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img