A 3/10 that might be generous – player ratings for Chelsea v Man Utd

This post was originally published on this site.

Rogers shines, 3/10 for sent-off Martinez – player ratings for Chelsea v Man Utd

Split image, with Morgan Rogers leaning on a corner flag and Lisandro Martinez looking pensiveImage source, Getty Images
ByNizaar KinsellaFootball reporter and Simon StoneChief football news reporter at Stamford Bridge
  • Published

Morgan Rogers and Cole Palmer scored second-half goals as Chelsea secured a 2-0 home win over 10-man Manchester United, who endured another desperate day.

Chelsea‘s record £117m signing Rogers opened the scoring in the 50th minute before United defender Lisandro Martinez was sent off after conceding a penalty, which Palmer converted.

Here’s how BBC Sport’s reporters at Stamford Bridge rated the players and your verdicts on the performances.

Chelsea

Mike Penders: The Belgian goalkeeper remains under pressure after his mistake against Tottenham last week, but he was steady here and made several comfortable saves. 7

Josh Acheampong: The young defender looked shaky early on but recovered well, making a fantastic block from a Bruno Fernandes volley and improving as the game went on. 6

Wesley Fofana: The Frenchman made a brilliant block from one of Amad Diallo’s shots but was twice at fault as the winger broke clear on the counter-attack. His header also struck the post after taking a deflection off Moises Caicedo in a chaotic display. Fofana also won the second-half penalty. 5

Levi Colwill: The England defender was part of an overall poor defensive display but did not make any obvious errors himself. 6

Marco Palestra: The Italian made some good recovery runs on his first start for Chelsea but was also part of a below-par defensive display from an organisational perspective. 7

Moises Caicedo: Influential presence in a scrappy midfield battle, helping Chelsea compete physically in the centre of the pitch. 6

Romeo Lavia: Often the player who helped Chelsea play through United’s pressure, sparking several counter-attacks with intelligent passing. Won the ball for Chelsea‘s opener. 7

Pedro Neto: Arguably Chelsea‘s most dangerous attacker but finishing let him down, with one effort saved and another fired well wide in the first half. 6

Cole Palmer: A quiet game by his standards and unconvincingly scored a second-half penalty. Aside from that, he attempted an ambitious effort from inside his own half and gifted United one of their major chances. 6

Estevao Willian: Lost possession with his first touch but recovered impressively. Looked lively throughout, having a couple of dangerous-looking shots on goal and two that he scored but were ruled out for offside. His set-pieces were also of consistent high quality. 8

Morgan Rogers: A surprisingly anonymous start and struggled in the number nine position until he was given the chance to run at United’s defence, scoring with a sublime dink in the 50th minute. 8

Subs:

Pep Chavarria (on 71, Palestra): Game was already won when he entered. 6

Malo Gusto (on 86, Pedro Neto)

Valentin Barco (on 86, Estevao Willian)

Danny Welbeck (on 86, Moises Caicedo)

Geovany Quenda on 90, Cole Palmer)

Manchester United

Senne Lammens: Alive to Palmer’s attempt to catch him out with a quickly taken free-kick. Was lucky to get away with a poor save early on, thanks to offside flag. Solid after that. No chance with Rogers goal. 7

Leny Yoro: Speed essential to deal with Chelsea counter-attacks but sometimes ran out of position. 7

Harry Maguire: Authoritative presence at heart of defence for most part but yet again unable to stop gap opening up for Rogers to score. 7

Lisandro Martinez: Did OK and looked good – until Chelsea scored. Then gave penalty away and red-carded for ridiculous moment of recklessness. 3

Diogo Dalot: Played out of position again at left-back and Estevao threatened down his side, but Dalot stuck to his task gamely. 6

Andrey Santos: So close to a memorable goal against his old club. Crucial intervention to deny Moises Caicedo a clear sight at goal at the other end. Difficult second half. 5

Carlos Baleba: Was having his best game in a United shirt so far and tried to prod the visitors forward. But impetuous tackle in midfield proved extremely costly as Rogers ran through to score. 5

Amad Diallo: Looked sharp. Tested Mike Penders from long range and also at his near post. Fofana blocked another goal-bound effort. Should have scored before half-time. 7

Bruno Fernandes: Returned as captain and should have put the visitors ahead when Mbeumo picked him out. Nearly set up Mbeumo. Better but not brilliant. 6

Matheus Cunha: Most impact of any recent game. Linked well with the visitors’ attack but didn’t threaten a goal. 6

Bryan Mbeumo: Set up a chance for Fernandes, then nearly reached a far-post cross from his captain. Gave Chelsea a problem but couldn’t get last bit right. 6

Subs:

Kobbie Mainoo (on 58, Baleba): Not on long enough to make an impact before Martinez red. After that it was damage limitation. 6

Ayden Heaven (on 66, Andrey Santos): Time for a regular start? 5

Mason Mount (on 66, Cunha): Usual abuse from the home fans and nothing to answer it with. 5

Joshua Zirkzee (on 77, Amad): 5

How did you rate the players?

The Player Rater cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable JavaScript or try another browser.

Player of the match

Number: 17 M. Rogers

Average rating 7.90
Number: 17 M. Rogers

Average Rating: 7.90

Number: 41 Estêvão

Average Rating: 7.66

Number: 10 C. Palmer

Average Rating: 7.20

Number: 45 R. Lavia

Average Rating: 7.05

Number: 39 M. Penders

Average Rating: 6.86

Number: 25 M. Caicedo

Average Rating: 6.82

Number: 7 Pedro Neto

Average Rating: 6.79

Number: 34 J. Acheampong

Average Rating: 6.70

Number: 6 L. Colwill

Average Rating: 6.55

Number: 2 M. Palestra

Average Rating: 6.28

Number: 29 Pep Chavarría

Average Rating: 6.04

Number: 4 V. Barco

Average Rating: 5.96

Number: 18 D. Welbeck

Average Rating: 5.92

Number: 27 M. Gusto

Average Rating: 5.75

Number: 23 Geovany Quenda

Average Rating: 5.68

Number: 3 W. Fofana

Average Rating: 5.58

After the opportunity to rate players has closed, the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users.

Hot this week

Why Nexa Law’s Eliot Hibbert wants lawyers to own their own practices

Eliot Hibbert is the founder and chief executive of...

Today’s Minute Cryptic Answer and Hints for November 1, 2026

For November 1, 2026, the Minute Cryptic is a...

99 Nights in the Forest Hedge Maze Refresh update patch notes 

99 Nights in the Forest is a survival and...

Edinburgh lose unbeaten URC record at hands of Benetton

Edinburgh lose unbeaten URC record at hands of BenettonImage...

How to complete Beyond the Margins quest in Crimson Desert DLC: Kliff walkthrough

In Crimson Desert, Beyond the Margins is a post-game...

Topics

Today’s Minute Cryptic Answer and Hints for November 1, 2026

For November 1, 2026, the Minute Cryptic is a...

Edinburgh lose unbeaten URC record at hands of Benetton

Edinburgh lose unbeaten URC record at hands of BenettonImage...

Lecce vs Genoa Prediction and Betting Tips | November 1st 2026

Genoa will look to continue their resurgence in the...

Usyk eyes ‘final chapter’ at cruiserweight against Benavidez

Former undisputed heavyweight champion Oleksandr Usyk is eyeing a return to cruiserweight to fight David Benavidez before retiring from boxing, says his adviser.

Usyk eyes ‘final chapter’ at cruiserweight against Benavidez

Usyk eyes 'final chapter' at cruiserweight against BenavidezByPaul BattisonBBC...
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img